Login or Sign Up

Why Kid Nation Is a Valuable Show For Kids

Laura3_thumb By LauraBelle 408 days ago Updated 405 days ago 269 Views 10 Comments
Rate This

Introduction

Kid Nation is one of the most talked about new shows, and it has received more than its share of criticism. People just don't seem to be comfortable with kids being as independent as these kids are. These 40 kids, ranging in age from 8 to 15, are left by themselves to live in an abandoned ghost town called Bonanza City. It's up to them to do everything, and many of these kids don't know the first thing about how to manage out there alone or as a group. Much of the criticism the show has received revolves around watching the kids struggle, and whether that's really right for us as adults to do to them. Yet, aside from this, there are still many reasons that show can be very valuable to kids.

1
 

Learning How to Be Self-Sufficient

Learning How to Be Self-Sufficient

While many of the kids walked into the show seemingly without even having any camping experience, they are learning how to take care of what needs to be done for their survival. No one there knew now to cook before they arrived there, and here they are all learning to cook, as if they don't ... they don't eat. It may be a hard way to learn the lesson, but regardless, they'll all know how to feed themselves, should they have to someday. Not only are they opening up a can of beans and warming it, but they're also learning how to make pasta, chicken noodle soup, etc. They're also learning how to clean outhouses (I'm sure their mothers are going to appreciate this one!), clean the dishes, and unfreeze water pipes.

23kidnation_wideweb__470x207_2_list_view

2
 

Learning How to Make Good Decisions

 
These kids are presented with big decisions on each show, and they need to decide as a town and by themselves what should be done. For themselves, they need to decide each show whether they want to stay or not, as they always have the option to leave the show. Yet, even though many of them have suffered through homesickness, only one child, the youngest at 8, has decided to leave. Winning challenges in certain amounts of time, the kids are given a choice of a need or a luxury, and make the decision together, even if not everyone is happy with it, such as deciding between extra outhouses or a television. They made the right decision to extend their one outhouse to five. Their most interesting decision came with the suggestion that chickens weren't only for laying eggs. To last a a number of days on their own, they would need protein. While no one wanted to kill the chickens, most of them came around in the long run to see that to eat healthy, it would have to be done, and realistically, it was no different than the chicken they were eating at home.
3
 

Learning How to Form a Society

 
These kids are left with a journal that was supposedly left by the last inhabitants of Bonanza City. While their town failed, they left this book behind to show the next inhabitants how to do it the right way. The kids are split up into four different groups and are each led by a council member. At the challenges, the teams compete to find out which rung on the social ladder they can claim for the next few days. The winning team becomes the upper class, not having to work unless they have to and making $1.oo. The second place team becomes the merchants that run the store, making $0.50, the third place team becomes the cooks, in charge of that and washing the dishes, making $0.50, and the last team are the laborers, in charge of cleaning and pumping water, and only make buffalo nickels. The sides become jealous of each other, complain about the jobs the different groups are doing, etc., and it only ends up echoing real life.
4
 

Learning How to Govern

 
They are now finding that the city council has to not only make good decisions for the whole group of kids, but they also need to help keep order in the town. The kids were staying up all night in the saloon drinking root beer, but then were finding it too hard to get up in the morning. The journal suggested setting a group curfew for Bonanza City, and while the council didn't like the idea outright, they knew it would help keep order. They weren't prepared for so many people to be against it, though, and told them that's the way it is, and they'll just have to live with it. They'd dint like it; but they did live with it.
5
 

Learning About History

 
From the journal that the council reads, the kids are also learning about history, about the original pioneers of the country somewhat, but mostly about life from the time of the gold rush. When the show is over, every one of them will know exactly what life was like for those that lived in the gold mining towns back then. Instead of panning for gold, though, the council awards one person each week with a gold star. They recipient will be the person they as a whole decided was the most helpful around Bonanza City that week. Receiving the gold star, they are told the gold star, which resembles a large paperweight, is worth its weight in gold, $20,000 for them and their parents to do whatever they want with it at the end of the show. The winner is allowed to call home and share the good news with their parents.
6
 

While They are Learning, They Are Having Fun

 
It's not all work for these kids; they have a lot of fun too! Sure they work a lot, and they get homesick, but they also have a tremendous amount of fun doing every single bit of it.

10 Comments

 

Lots of good thinks on Kid Nation. Great list.
Pam-oml-avatar-2_thumb Pamposted 407 days ago
I have not seen this show, but of course that won't keep me from commenting! :)

I wonder if some will not have a form of post traumatic shock syndrome because of the sink or swim immersion.

Another thought, we underestimate kids.
I do history articles and MANY (as today,really) were on their own by the age of 10. I know of several (8 year old cattle herder, 11 year old joined wagon train west, 14 year old orphan became physician...)
K_sunglasses_thumb kathybelleposted 407 days ago
Those are good points, Kathy. I think it will be interesting to see what happens to these kids after. There was a family that was followed around by PBS years ago; it must have been like the birth of reality TV. They checked back in on that family every every few years as they went thought a variety of differnt things in the family. I think that would be interesting to do with this group of kids. To see if they all become an extremely successful bunch, or if there's a trauma there that they can't seem to get rid of. One thing that made me wonder how much parental influence went into these kids coming on the show, was one of the girls that was very upset about the killing of the chickens. She said my mom told me to come on the show and be a cowgirl, so I'm trying to be the best one I can be. It almost sounded like she was pushed, but that could just be the way this young girl is explaining it.
Laura3_thumb LauraBelleposted 407 days ago
its a very interesting show on many levels. i hope some of them aren't scarred in the process, such as being put in the position to watch a chicken's head get cut off at the age of about 10 or so...that's not going to stop me from watching it though, it is entertaining. i am a little curious of the parents motivations for sending their children on the show, did they know of the possibility of the money and the gold star? i surely would not have sent my child on this show...and the little pageant queen, she needs to go. her parents have not lived up to their responsibilities. i hope that the town council can change. there are some good things for these kids to learn, but i think they should set up more dire consequences if a team or individual does not fulfill their respective responsibilities.
Metrsm_thumb peteronmylistposted 407 days ago
that's something I keep thinking. Every old ghost town has a jail. Why have we not seen one for Bonanza City? Are they thinking that's not suitable for these kids and the show, or are they holding that for later? If they had something like that, surely Greg would be headed there, but he's shown he's motivated by rewards and probably punishment as well, so maybe that would help him behave.
Laura3_thumb LauraBelleposted 407 days ago
Okay. I am very curious now. I will try to tune in. Tomorrow?

I would think this would provide a great opportunity for a follow up study.

I also wonder how accurate the TV portrayal really is. Editing for rating has to be their top priority.
K_sunglasses_thumb kathybelleposted 407 days ago
Yes, it's on Wednesday nights. It will be interesting to see what you think after getting all this background on it. There has to be some manipulation at some point for ratings, like with most reality TV.
Laura3_thumb LauraBelleposted 407 days ago
Well, now I speak from watching ONE show...

I don't think there will be any post traumatic stresses. They actually have a lot of structure, planned game-like events AND they get to choose to go home. That is THE salvaging factor.

The religion delimma I found hard to believe. It has been my experience in a group of 40 kids, there would only be a few who felt intolerant toward another's faith - not a whole camp! When they gathered together and said whatever prayer they wanted - that seemed real to me.
Kids will accept a different faith better than a different hairstyle!

Little Taylor - she's interesting to watch, a manipulative little powerhouse. Will she topple?

Zach - Can he organize a peace corp and de-thrown the dictator?

Jordan - A sweetie. Her family will be well nurtured.

That little survey taker...cute. He will work with the numbers many of us avoid.

I was impressed and felt validated in my belief kids will rise to the occasion - if only we adults will let them.

I plan to see it again next week.
Thanks for the heads up! :)
K_sunglasses_thumb kathybelleposted 405 days ago
Glad you enjoyed the show, Kathy. I haven't watched last night's episode yet, but I'll get to it sooner or later. I had read, though, about the kids choosing between the Bible and something else. I think they do okay there, and I just see them getting such an incredible learning experience.
Laura3_thumb LauraBelleposted 405 days ago
All these things apply to "It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia" with the added bonus of Danny Devito and swearing.
Farva_thumb the kingposted 405 days ago
Quick List Ideas Your 5 favorite bands Your bucket list The 10 best movies of all time Things you can't live without

Most Popular Lists Today

Latest TV Lists

View More TV Lists

Upping participation

Posted by Noah 276 days ago

I’ve been spending lots of time trying to think of ways to…

Read More